Opinion: The Cost of Omission: Ottawa’s Budgetary Silence on Indigenous Women

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire
While the federal government aggressively pursues corporate accountability and industrial expansion, its failure to fund essential safety services for Indigenous women reveals a calculated abandonment of the most vulnerable.
The federal government's latest budget presents a stark contradiction in priorities. While Prime Minister Mark Carney’s administration is quick to label corporate failures as a "betrayal," its own budgetary omissions regarding Indigenous women suggest a systemic failure to protect those facing the most acute risks in the country.
According to reporting by CityNews Toronto, a collective of Indigenous women’s organizations has called out Ottawa for failing to include targeted funding for community support services and violence prevention in the new budget. The federal government has allocated $3.6 million for Indigenous women, which includes funding for an alert system for missing persons and efforts to address the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women. However, Josie Nepinak, president of the Native Women’s Association of Canada (NWAC), argues that the safety of Indigenous women cannot be treated as a "secondary factor" or rely on short-term funding cycles.
This lack of sustained investment is particularly glaring when contrasted with the government's industrial ambitions. Cora McGuire-Cyrette, CEO of the Ontario Native Women’s Association (ONWA), noted that Canada is currently mobilizing billions to expand industries and speed up major project development. This economic push often increases the risks faced by Indigenous women. Citing reports from Amnesty International, the risk is compounded by a shortage of childcare and high housing prices, which, combined with drug and alcohol use among transient resource workers, can lead to the exploitation of Indigenous women and girls.
The failure to prioritize safety is not a new oversight, but a continuation of a long-term pattern of neglect. A 2019 inquiry into missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls—which drew testimony from over 2,380 experts, survivors, and family members—found that Indigenous women are 12 times more likely to be murdered or go missing than non-Indigenous women. Despite the commission issuing 231 calls to action to address what it termed a "genocide," the collective of women's organizations reports that little progress has been made seven years later.
Ottawa's capacity for aggressive intervention is evident in other sectors. As reported by Global News Toronto, Industry Minister Mélanie Joly recently served the automaker Stellantis with a notice of default, alleging the company breached a 2022 funding agreement by closing its Brampton, Ont. plant and selling it to Roshel. In that instance, Prime Minister Mark Carney described the Roshel deal as a "partial solution" for workers and termed the lack of a global solution a "betrayal." The federal government had previously committed up to $529 million to help Stellantis retool facilities in Windsor and Brampton.
Yet, when it comes to the lives of Indigenous women, that same urgency is absent. The collective of organizations stated they met with Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Rebecca Alty to outline their priorities, but those requests were ignored in the final budget. For the government, the "betrayal" is only a priority when it involves corporate contracts and industrial output. For Indigenous women, the result is a calculated abandonment that leaves them to navigate systemic violence and poverty without a federal safety net.

