The Math of 'Affordability': Scrutinizing Toronto's 10,000-Unit Promise

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire
City Hall touts nearly 10,000 new rentals through its incentive program, but a closer look at the numbers reveals a stark divide between market-rate units and those designated as affordable.
OPINION: In the world of municipal press releases, the number 10,000 is designed to sound like a victory. On November 16, 2026, as the City of Toronto first reported, the city announced the results of Phase 2 of its Purpose-Built Rental (PBR) Housing Incentives stream, claiming the move brings nearly 10,000 new rental homes closer to construction.
But for those of us tracking the affordability crisis, the headline figure is a distraction. The real story lies in the ratio of market-rate housing to the units actually designated as affordable for the people being priced out of this city.
The City of Toronto's PBR program mandates that projects designate at least 20 percent of their units as rent-controlled, affordable homes. In Phase 2, the City selected 19 projects across 12 wards. While these projects will provide 9,667 new rental homes, only 2,059 of those are classified as affordable.
When we combine the outcomes of Phase 1 and Phase 2, the disparity becomes even more evident. The City of Toronto reports that these two phases will support 34 rental housing developments, resulting in over 13,000 market rental homes and just over 3,800 affordable, rent-controlled homes.
To get these units built, the City is deploying significant public resources. The City of Toronto estimates it is providing $894.2 million in financial incentives across these 34 developments. These incentives include exemptions from property taxes, waivers of building permit fees, and an indefinite deferral of development charges for market rental homes.
Mayor Olivia Chow stated that if people live and work in Toronto, they should be able to afford to live here. However, the mechanism for achieving this relies heavily on the private sector's willingness to meet a 20 percent threshold. Even the Phase 2 application pool suggests a gap between ambition and reality: the City received 58 applications representing approximately 27,000 rental homes, with more than 5,600 designated as affordable—a rate of roughly 20.7 percent.
While Councillor Chiara Padovani (York South-Weston) highlighted the creation of 89 rent-controlled homes at The Dennis under Phase 1 as a positive step, the broader question remains: is a 20 percent mandate enough to move the needle for the median earner?
As the City moves forward, it is utilizing $1.5 billion in funding from the province and federal government via the Development Charges Reduction Program to lower developer charges and support essential infrastructure, such as water, roads, and transit. While the City argues these investments help Torontonians across a range of incomes, the sheer volume of market-rate units compared to affordable ones suggests that the primary beneficiary of this 'shovels in the ground' approach may be the developers rather than the city's most vulnerable renters.

