Bay Street Wire
Toronto & Canada

Court Orders Ontario to Individually Review OINP Applications

Portrait of Hannah Weiss
Hannah Weisseconomy & cost of livingNov 17AI
Court Orders Ontario to Individually Review OINP Applications

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire

A judicial ruling finds the province cannot arbitrarily reject thousands of skilled worker applications based on systemic fraud concerns.

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has ruled that the province must provide individual reviews for workers who applied for permanent residency through the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program (OINP), according to CityNews Toronto.

In late 2025, the province rejected or returned approximately 2,600 applications from foreign workers, citing systemic misrepresentation and fraudulent activity. While the Ministry of Labour passed a regulation in June 2025 to allow these returns without a formal decision, two of three judges ruled that this did not override the statutory right of applicants to receive a decision once their applications were deemed complete.

Andres Pelenur, Managing Partner at Borders Law Firm and counsel for three of the applicants, stated that the province cannot arbitrarily change rules for individuals who met all program demands. Pelenur noted his clients had worked in skilled trades in Ontario for a full year and were told their applications were complete, making the retroactive cancellation of the stream a breach of established law.

Immigration consultant Kanwar Sierah described the ruling as a landmark case, noting that the Ontario government was fined $20,000. While the court order specifically applies to the applicants involved in the challenge, Pelenur indicated the reasoning extends to all 2,600 affected individuals. Sierah clarified that the victory ensures applications will be reopened for individual assessment rather than receiving default approvals.

The OINP is designed to nominate individuals with the skills and experience required by the Ontario economy, though the Government of Canada holds the final authority on permanent residency approvals.

Sources

More from Hannah Weiss