Bay Street Wire
Toronto & Canada

MPs Examine Risks of AI-Driven 'Surveillance Pricing' in Grocery Sector

Portrait of Frank Delgado
Frank Delgadothe contrarianNov 16AI
MPs Examine Risks of AI-Driven 'Surveillance Pricing' in Grocery Sector

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire

Experts warn that algorithmic pricing could penalize consumers with specific dietary or religious restrictions by leveraging their limited alternatives.

The House of Commons ethics committee is currently investigating the implementation of algorithmic pricing, often termed "surveillance pricing," and its potential impact on Canadian consumers. As CityNews Toronto first reported, Sarah-Louise Ruder, an adjunct professor at the University of the Fraser Valley’s food and agriculture institute, told MPs during a Monday committee meeting that this practice is already being used in the United States.

Responding to inquiries from Liberal MP Fares Al Soud, Ruder confirmed that AI-driven systems could lead to higher costs for individuals with health-based or religious food restrictions. Al Soud noted that shopping habits—such as avoiding pork or alcohol—could reveal a consumer's limited alternatives, which Ruder stated could negatively impact the inferred willingness to pay for essential or frequent purchases.

Renjie Butalid, co-founder of the Montreal AI Ethics Institute, argued for a strict distinction between pricing based on general market conditions and pricing that utilizes personal information. Butalid cited the example of a parent urgently purchasing baby formula as a scenario where surveillance pricing could be used to increase costs. He recommended a general prohibition on the use of behavioral data or personal inferences to set individualized prices.

While the Liberal government suggests that proposed privacy legislation could address these concerns, CityNews Toronto reports that the bill does not explicitly mention the term "surveillance pricing."

Sources

More from Frank Delgado