Beyond the Skubal Noise: The Rotation Desperation Play

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire
While the industry obsesses over Tarik Skubal's landing spot, the real story is the fragmented approach GMs are taking to rebuild their pitching staffs.
Q: The chatter coming out of the General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas centered heavily on Tarik Skubal. Is that where the real action is?
A: In my view, the Skubal noise is a distraction. While, as MLB first reported, nearly everyone expects the two-time American League Cy Young Award winner to sign with the New York Mets, the broader market is actually defined by a desperate need for volume over a single superstar. The Mets have the financial means and the need to secure Skubal, but other teams are realizing that one arm doesn't fix a broken rotation.
Q: Which teams are explicitly avoiding the "one big splash" approach in favor of depth?
A: According to MLB, the San Diego Padres have expressed interest in Skubal, but a source indicates they would rather spread their funds across two or three pitchers to rebuild their rotation instead of spending it all on one player. Similarly, MLB reports that the Chicago Cubs are seeking rotation help, but because most of their rotation is currently on the free-agent market, they will likely pursue multiple arms rather than going all-in on Skubal.
Q: What are the specific roadblocks preventing other suitors from landing Skubal?
A: It comes down to structure and spending. MLB reports that the Los Angeles Dodgers prefer a shorter-term deal with a high average annual value, similar to the four-year, $240 million contract Kyle Tucker signed last winter. However, sources say Skubal wants a long-term pact. As for the Toronto Blue Jays, MLB notes that while they will take a serious look at him, it is difficult to see them topping the Mets in a bidding war.
Q: If teams aren't going all-in on Skubal, what does the rest of the starting pitching market look like?
A: It is a split market. MLB reports that top starters like Michael King, Freddy Peralta, Clay Holmes, and Trevor Rogers should secure multi-year deals of at least three years. There is also a contingent of pitchers over 35—specifically Sonny Gray (37), Kevin Gausman (36), and Nick Martinez (36)—who could still land multi-year contracts. However, for the rest of the starting pitching class, an executive told MLB that there is a strong appetite for one- or two-year deals, with little interest in longer terms.
Q: Was there any actual movement during the meetings at the Aria Resort and Casino?
A: Very little. MLB reports that while some expected "mayhem" due to the Collective Bargaining Agreement expiring on Dec. 1, the market remained largely stagnant. The only notable signings reported by MLB were Evan Phillips (three years, $35 million with the Braves), Emilio Pagán (one year, $11.5 million with the Tigers), and Ryan Weiss (one year, $1.85 million with the Padres).

