Bay Street Wire
Toronto & Canada

App Data Scans Reveal Discrepancies in Privacy Practices

Portrait of Dana Feldman
Dana Feldmandata journalismNov 14AI
App Data Scans Reveal Discrepancies in Privacy Practices

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire

A Marketplace investigation into six popular Canadian apps shows data collection extending to device fingerprints and sensitive search queries.

As CBC's Marketplace first reported, an investigation into six of Canada's most popular Android and iOS apps—Tim Hortons, PC Optimum, the Weather Network, Facebook, Amazon, and YouTube—has revealed that the data these apps collect and share often exceeds what users may realize.

To conduct the analysis, Joel Reardon, an associate professor at the University of Calgary, and his team scanned network traffic on Android devices. Additionally, Privo, an organization focused on U.S. child privacy law compliance, performed scans on iOS devices. Analyst Celeste Rollason, a former Privo employee, assisted in the evaluation.

**Tim Hortons** Network scans indicated the Tim Hortons app transmits data to third-party companies immediately upon launch. According to Reardon, one overseas third-party company collects enough information to create a "digital fingerprint" for each device. This data includes: * The device name * A unique device identifier * A list of device sensors * Camera specifications (e.g., lens size) * Ringtone and alarm sound names * Nearby Wi-Fi router names, which Reardon stated can be used to determine location.

Rollason described the volume of data as "excessive" for validating coffee purchases. Michael Oliveira, director of communications for Tim Hortons, stated the third party collects this data solely for payment abuse, account protection, and fraud prevention, rather than marketing or advertising. Oliveira further asserted that Tim Hortons does not sell personal information to data brokers or third-party companies and that the third party is prohibited from selling the data.

**PC Optimum** Testing revealed the PC Optimum app sends information regarding user product searches—including sensitive items like prenatal vitamins—to 10 different outside companies. One third-party company received a unique device identifier along with the user's latitude and longitude.

Additionally, the app sent the following details to an overseas third party: * User's first name * Unredacted email address * PC Optimum member number * A unique device identifier * User interaction data, including app opening times and in-app activity.

Reardon and Rollason questioned the necessity of sharing search data with 10 outside companies for the app to function. In a statement, Loblaw, the company behind PC Optimum, stated it has never sold personal information and that the collected data supports features such as finding nearby stores and online shopping.

Reardon characterized the current state of mobile data collection as a "monstrous data collection surveillance system."

Sources

More from Dana Feldman